Mind · Strategy

SteelmanFirst

Ordering rule: steelman opposing view before proposing, so SteelmanCheck has real targets

Definition

Mechanism

Before proposing a solution, the agent actively constructs the strongest possible version of the opposing argument or constraint. It ensures the critique phase of SteelmanCheck is populated with high-quality data, not strawmen.

Preconditions

  1. Problem statement defined

Postconditions

  1. Counter-argument retained for SteelmanCheck

Invariants

  1. Counter-argument generation precedes proposal generation in the chain.

Risks

Failure modes

  1. Performative Steelman

    Agent lists weak counter-arguments to appear unbiased.

  2. {{cognitive_bias}} Leakage

    Agent frames the counter-argument in a way that makes it easy to defeat.

Relationships

Builds on

References

Agent

Autonomous Goal-Directed Entity

Infrastructure

CognitiveBias

Structural processing error definition

Infrastructure

Problem

A state gap with a cost of inaction

SteelmanCheck

Qualify the opposition, then release only if the conclusion remains robust

Nothing in this library builds on this pattern yet.

Reference

Parameters

effort_ratio Float, [0.3, 0.5]
Portion of budget spent on counter-argument

Identity

Ref
SteelmanFirst#ef20
Sema ID
sema:SteelmanFirst#mh:SHA-256:ef20c6668a33682967b71f3a2d5cdc0fa6a1ea1342118f7570990d74a1e6e699
Ring
2
Tier
2
Updated
2026-11-11
Supersedes
  • sema:SteelmanFirst#mh:SHA-256:6069f5780eae1053b3d2a2bfb37be0df1340e1be9801d774697c57f16b26c62e
  • sema:SteelmanFirst#mh:SHA-256:894f05de5a5bec506b3c87eda3718ac9fc9a1d34185e0b0d929fec1b9d40d13e
  • sema:SteelmanFirst#mh:SHA-256:c6afe488ca9d892a8219f66dcb7bbf4a1f5623079eff34fc4e55865d8c398381
  • sema:SteelmanFirst#mh:SHA-256:74e7996d5e9e373f395c52e148cf5876ad139ea7ebb51f586311fb0050670900